Is it possible for a human being of sound mind and body to eat the horrifying banana and mayo “favorite sandwich” of NASCAR driver Dale Earnhardt Jr.? Watch us find out!

Dale Jr. (Go Dale!) tweeted yesterday that he loved the sandwich, clearly exposing him as some kind of horror monster of epic proportions:

Or so I thought! As it turns out, Dale Jr. (Go Dale!) is not the only person who loves this sandwich, and apparently it’s A Thing down south. That tweet has nearly 3,000 likes at the time of publishing.

We roped in a couple of our coworkers at Gawker Media to see what they thought as well.