Haggling With Car Dealers Is Great, Say Car Dealers In Grating Cartoon

Illustration for article titled Haggling With Car Dealers Is Great, Say Car Dealers In Grating Cartoon

Not long ago the National Automobile Dealers Association (NADA) made a video to tell consumers how "misguided" there were to think that Tesla's direct sales model was that better than the franchise model. Now the NADA wants to tell you how wonderful it is to negotiate your car deal.

This video highlights the "benefits of price competition" and tries to prove the point that negotiating to buy a car is so easy and stress free for the consumer that dealers really aren't making much money.


The NADA is clearly responding to a recent Edmund's ad that shows the ridiculousness of haggling for items in your grocery store. Of course since Edmunds makes their money from dealerships, they pulled the ad. But conversation continued, despite Edmunds saying that their video"portrays a buying experience so far from the way modern dealerships operate," most viewers thought the grocery store clerk had an uncanny resemblance to how their dealership acted the last time they bought a car.

So the NADA video does get a few things right, primarily that dealers don't make much money on new car sales and that dealership competition and online pricing tools have made margins slim. It also addresses the fact that profit margins on other items like furniture are way higher than automobiles.

Here is what the video conveniently glosses over, while online shopping and multiple dealerships within the same area should result in a competitive buying experience that favors the consumer, often times this is not the case. In large metro areas, often dealers have numbers to their advantage and won't waste their time with savvy internet shoppers when they have hundreds of suckers that walk through the door. Also, while dealers aren't making much on the sale of the vehicle some of them are finding ways to make that money on the "back end" of the deal.


The reality is despite all the resources the internet gives car shoppers, most of them still feel like they are being taken for a ride every time they buy a car. Most people despise the process.

Nine out of 10 car shoppers would be more excited to purchase a vehicle if it had a set price they felt good about, rather than having to haggle


This is precisely why third party web-sites like TrueCar and Edmund's Price Promise are gaining popularity, because they promise a "transparent" car buying process. But despite these tools the vast majority of buyers want to buy a car like they buy an iPad. They want a choice between purchasing from the factory or from a franchised store, and consumers know that the dealerships are standing in their way from doing this.


If you have a question, a tip, or something you would like to to share about car-buying, drop me a line at AutomatchConsulting@gmail.com and be sure to include your Kinja handle.

Share This Story

Get our `newsletter`



I manage a credit union and a lot of our business is refinance of existing loans ... In just the last year I have seen an explosion dealer shenanigans recently I saw a deal where a 500 score customer got 8 % for 78 months on a 5 year old truck ..of course by the time you added $3k for ext service $1800.00 for GAP plus additional for CL and Disability a 100k "maint agreement "(oil changes and tire rotation for $2k ) and rolled in $9k of negative equity as they STOLE his trade you have a man in a 5 year old car financed for 6.5 years starting off at 135% loan to value ....but they got him the payment he wanted .....I hate car dealers .....................