Popular Cars Consumer Reports Recommends You Skip In Favor Of Something Better
Even if they cost a little more, you'll probably be happier with the alternatives
You would think that the most popular vehicles on the road would be some of the best. But that's not necessarily the case. Whether it's brand loyalty, a friend who works at a certain dealership, lack of time to test-drive more than a few options or a less-than-ideal dealership experience, a lot of people end up driving cars that aren't as good as the competition.
If you'd like to avoid that mistake on your next purchase, Consumer Reports put together a list of some incredibly popular vehicles that you may be tempted to buy but should actually avoid. But the article wasn't entirely negative. It also includes alternatives that are better buys based on its testing and subscriber survey data.
Avoid: Ford Explorer
As popular as the Ford Explorer is, Consumer Reports found it to be pretty disappointing compared to other three-row SUVs. Its reliability also leaves a lot to be desired.
Buy Instead: Kia Telluride
While the Explorer does a few things well, the Kia Telluride does pretty much everything well. It's also Consumer Reports' top pick among three-row SUVs.
Avoid: Hyundai Elantra
If you buy a new Elantra, you'll probably enjoy it, and we don't blame you. The problem is that the Elantra has below-average reliability that could come back to bite you in a few years.
Buy Instead: Toyota Corolla Hybrid
The Toyota Corolla Hybrid is far from the most exciting compact sedan, but it gets great gas mileage, should be more reliable than the Elantra and is pretty cheap, too
Avoid: Toyota RAV4
The Toyota RAV4 isn't a terrible choice. It's just that the interior, engine refinement and ride quality could be better.
Buy Instead: Subaru Forester
According to Consumer Reports, Subaru has pretty much out-RAV4-ed Toyota. It's roomy, comfortable and fuel-efficient, and you don't have to pay extra for all-wheel drive.
Avoid: Chrysler Pacifica
The Chrysler Pacifica is a great family hauler that's let down by a lack of refinement that other minivans also offer. It's also proven less reliable than its competition.
Buy Instead: Kia Carnival
Since it's newer than the Pacifica, the Kia Carnival feels more modern. It also offers most of what you get in the Pacifica while also being more reliable.
Avoid: Toyota Tacoma
People love the Toyota Tacoma because it's reliable, but the ride, handling and engine leave a lot to be desired. The upcoming redesigned Tacoma should be better, but for now, you can find more compelling trucks.
Buy Instead: Honda Ridgeline
Say what you will about the Honda Ridgeline not being a real truck, but as a daily driver, it's hard to beat. What you give up in off-road capability, you gain in comfort and refinement.
Avoid: Volkswagen ID.4
The Volkswagen ID.4 probably won't make you hate it, but its range is only adequate, the infotainment system is buggy and reliability is below average.
Buy Instead: Kia EV6
According to Consumer Reports, the Kia EV6 beats the ID.4 in pretty much every way you can think of. It has better range, acceleration, handling, braking and efficiency.
Avoid: Mercedes-Benz C-Class
If you have to have a Mercedes, then the C-Class is probably the only compact luxury sedan you'll consider. But Consumer Reports didn't like its stiff ride, confusing controls and below-average predicted reliability.
Buy Instead: Lexus ES Hybrid
The Lexus ES isn't a Mercedes, but it still offers plenty of luxury in a much more reliable package. Plus, if you spring for the hybrid, it gets an EPA-rated 44 mpg combined.
Avoid: Volvo XC60
When you first climb inside the Volvo XC60, you'll probably be as impressed with the cabin as you are with the exterior styling. But it's going to be hard to justify buying it after you turn it on and realize the driving experience doesn't live up to the XC60's good looks.
Buy Instead: Lexus NX Hybrid
The Lexus NX doesn't look as good as the Volvo XC60. That's just a fact. But if you get the hybrid, the NX is both quicker and more fuel efficient than the XC60.
Avoid: Ford F-150
There's no denying that the Ford F-150 is popular. But Consumer Reports found that the ride, handling and reliability don't measure up against some of the competition.
Buy Instead: Ram 1500
The Ram 1500 is plenty capable, just like the F-150. But where it really beats the F-150 is in its ride, making it a much more enjoyable truck to drive daily.