Vote 2020 graphic
Everything you need to know about and expect during
the most important election of our lifetimes

Formula One Has a Penalty Problem

Illustration for article titled Formula One Has a Penalty Problem
Image: AP Images

In spite of the fact that Max Verstappen was finally able to break Mercedes’ stranglehold on the 2019 Formula One season victories and score the first race win for a Honda engine in over a decade, there is a larger story in the paddock today; F1 is quick to consider any form of contretemps penalty-worthy. With three of the last four races decided by penalty, or in this case lack thereof, the penalty process has become more important and more talked about than the drivers, the teams, or the cars. That’s not an indicator of a healthy sport.


If you didn’t catch the pass that decided the Austrian Grand Prix on Sunday, check it out from multiple angles above. Within seconds of Verstappen’s pass on erstwhile race leader Charles Leclerc, the stewards let everyone know that the pass was under review. With three laps to go in the grand prix. And the decision to take no further action, thus allowing Verstappen to keep his well-earned victory, took more than three hours to mete out.


While I commend the stewards to ultimately coming to the correct decision, that neither Verstappen or Leclerc were to blame for the contact, or at least equally to blame, it hurts me to my core that the sport has devolved to a series of stewards decisions and off-the-track fighting. By delaying the decision until most of the fans had left the circuit, and perhaps some had even arrived back home, the high of the great battle between Red Bull and Ferrari was allowed to fade and the doldrums of waiting for a steward to balance the scales give this a sour taste.

Call me an old-fashioned fuddy duddy, but I vehemently believe in letting the racers race. I’m generally opposed to most penalties for contact, blocking, or passing outside the bounds of the track. If one driver makes it to the finish before the other, they’ve won. And while I’m hardly a NASCAR fan, I wholeheartedly agree with that series’ policy to declare a winner and let that victory stand. Let the fans see a winner. Don’t even cast the doubt.

While many agreed with Verstappen’s penalty for unsafe release in the pit lane at Monaco, I’m not sure I did. While many agreed with Vettel’s penalty for returning to the race course in an unsafe manner in Canada, I definitely did not. Let racers race, trust that they know what they’re doing. Stewards shouldn’t treat the sport as if it’s competitive holding the door open for the person behind you at 7/11. There’s no room for polite on the track, it should be a knock down drag out. It should be what we saw this sunny Sunday in Austria, and then some.

Jalopnik contributor with a love for everything sketchy and eclectic.

Share This Story

Get our newsletter



My problem is it’s starting to become like football/soccer.

People will start fishing for penalties.

In the latest two examples I think it would be hard to say that the thought didnt cross their minds (Hamilton and Leclerc) if I do this he might get a penalty.

Leclerc knew he lost the corner he also knew he couldnt catch Verstappen after that so why force the issue into contact?

Same thing with Hamilton in Canada. He saw Vettel go off. He knew there was nowhere for him to go and yet he stuck his car up there.

Which is all great racing. Except when you have drivers IMMEDIATELY on the radio “did you see that! Can you believe that happened! Call the stewards!!!!”

Its akin to the footballer rolling on the field holding his shin because he walked into another player and begging for a yellow card.

Its racing we dont need it. Outwardly dangerous drivers at this level will get weeded out and should be penalized but they are a different scenario.

Most of what the stewards are doing these days is playing in to some whinging players hands.