Dumbest HOA Ever Gives Up On Open Garage Door Policy

Image: The Sacramento Bee (screengrab)
Image: The Sacramento Bee (screengrab)

A homeowners’ association in Auburn, California has rescinded its imbecilic policy that allegedly forced owners to keep their overhead doors open from 8 a.m. to 4 p.m. Monday through Friday, The Sacramento Bee reports. Thank goodness—perhaps there is hope for this world yet.


According to Sacramento-based news channel KCRA 3, the Auburn Greens complex HOA in Placer County, California decided in the fall to enact a policy aimed at preventing people from living in garages. That policy, a work of true brilliance, required residents to keep their garage doors open during the day, or else face a $200 fine.

Obviously, keeping garages—which are often filled with valuables—open for anyone to enter is a bad idea, so now it looks like the HOA has come to its senses:

The Sacramento Bee stopped by the HOA’s office and found on a bulletin board the following message retracting the aforementioned policy:

Dear resident, the new garage Door Policy has been put on hold by the Board of Directors effective immediately. You may keep your garage doors down until further notice. The Board of Directors will be working with the Membership (Homeowners) to hopefully come up with a more ‘reasonable’ policy.

The newspaper spoke with a resident, who said he hadn’t been notified of the change in the rule, so perhaps the HOA hasn’t gotten around to letting its constituents know.

The more interesting part of The Sacramento Bee’s story, though, is the comment from a landlord named James Croci. He provides a bit of context for the HOA’s open-door policy, telling the newspaper that the neighborhood used to just be a bunch of fourplexes with carports, which were meant to be maintained by the HOA.


After a while, he said, residents started installing overhead doors, and eventually, “transients” began sneaking into side doors and living in the garages. Croci, who had positive things to say about the HOA in general, claimed the garage doors really weren’t supposed to be there, telling the newspaper:

You’re not allowed to install garage doors...The ones you see were grandfathered in.


Still, if folks weren’t supposed to install garage doors, you’d think that should have been enforced at the time. Now that the doors have been in place for a while (and presumably some residents assumed they’d have a closed garage when moving in), requiring folks to keep them open still seems silly.

Hopefully the neighborhood and the HOA can work together on a more logical solution.

Sr. Tech Editor, Jalopnik. Owner of far too many Jeeps (Including a Jeep Comanche). Follow my instagram (@davidntracy). Always interested in hearing from engineers—email me.



I love how the HOA announcement throws quotations around the word “reasonable.”