American Auto Repair Pros And Cons

Pros Customizable coverage Benefits like roadside assistance A+ BBB rating Mostly positive customer reviews
Cons Maximum term limits not available online No sample contracts online Few customer reviews

Every new car comes with a manufacturer’s warranty, but coverage expires after a few years. American Auto Repair Coverage provides vehicle service contracts that step in and cover repairs after that point. In this article, we’ll look at the company’s reputation and coverage options compared to leading providers on the market.

There are dozens of options for extended coverage today. We’ve reviewed the best extended warranty companies in the industry to help drivers find dependable plans. Get free quotes from a few leading providers to find the best coverage for your vehicle.

Why Trust Our Review Team Our review team has spent hundreds of hours researching car warranty companies to help consumers choose the best coverage for their vehicles. Writers and editors evaluate each brand based on industry data and real customers’ experiences, meeting high editorial standards to keep readers informed.
Research Hours
860 Research Hours
Companies Reviewed
77 Companies Reviewed
Reviews Analyzed
2,000 Customers Surveyed

American Auto Repair Review: 3.5 Stars

American Auto Repair Coverage holds up its end of the bargain and covers car repairs under contract. It offers a decent range of coverage options, but the website doesn’t include sample contracts or details on maximum term limits. If the price is right and you want to buy this coverage, a plan from AARC is a safe choice.







Customer Experience


Overall Rating


About American Auto Repair Coverage

American Auto Repair Coverage (AARC) has over a decade of experience in the warranty industry. According to its website, the company pays out $22 million for auto repairs per year on average. It gets mostly positive reviews from customers, and it has an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau (BBB).

American Auto Repair Coverage sells plans across the U.S. that are administered by a number of different companies, including:

  • Enterprise Financial Group
  • Allegiance
  • Omnisure Group
  • CarGuard
  • Omega AutoCare
  • SunPath
  • Matrix Protection

Something interesting to point out is that AARC lets drivers customize plans by selecting exactly what systems they want covered on the contract. Other companies offer different add-ons, but not many companies let drivers build the entire contract.

American Auto Pros And Cons

Pros Customizable coverage Benefits like roadside assistance A+ BBB rating Mostly positive customer reviews
Cons Maximum term limits not available online No sample contracts online Few customer reviews

Cost Of An American Auto Repair Coverage

When you get a quote from AARC, the price will depend on the make, model, and mileage of your vehicle. Coverage typically costs more for vehicles with more miles since the likelihood of repairs is also higher. Not all vehicles will be eligible for all types of coverage.

In our research, we found that plans cost between $350 and $650 per year of coverage from most leading providers. American Auto Repair Coverage claims to offer affordable plans, so you can use this range as a guide if you get a quote. AARC allows drivers to do monthly installments at no extra cost, as well.

How American Auto Repair Extended Warranties Work

Getting a quote from AARC is a straightforward process. You just have to enter your contact information and the year, make, model, and mileage of your car. If you want to customize your plan, you can click the checkboxes next to each system of the vehicle.

The only downside is that quotes aren’t instant. You’ll have to wait for a call or email from an AARC specialist to find out what you’d pay.

Warranties are cancellable, but the site does not list a guarantee policy. If you sell your car, you can also transfer the policy to the secondary owner. In some cases, this can add to the resale value of your car.

American Auto Repair Coverage pays the repair shop directly for covered claims, which include shop fees and taxes. To file a claim, connect the dealership or repair shop with the AARC claims number, and the company will handle the rest.

American Auto Repair Coverage Reviews

American Auto Repair Coverage has mostly positive reviews online, though it has relatively few reviews in total compared to leading providers. On the BBB, the company has about a dozen complaints and negative reviews, which is a very small number. American Auto Repair Coverage has responded to all of them and has issued refunds when necessary.

Almost all positive reviews mention paid claims, which is a good sign. Here are a few examples of positive and negative reviews:

“American Auto Repair has saved me and my wife twice already! I set up the coverage in 2017 and they have already paid out $1,800 in engine claims and $1,200 for an alternator. This policy has more than paid for itself already!”
– Greg D., BBB

“I had extended the coverage on my vehicle, just in case! A few months later my transmission went out and I would have been saddled with an unpayable bill, but thanks to the extended warranty I was able to have my car back on the road in about a week or so.”
– John O., BBB

“American Auto Repair won’t refund me my $1,800. They are a rip off. These warranty repair companies are just ripping folk off. Never had to use the warranty.”
– Dorothy A., BBB

AARC responded to the last review and noted that the customer had not paid their policy for the two months prior. According to the contract, refunds are no longer available when an account is canceled due to nonpayment, which is what happened.

Top Recommendations For Extended Car Warranties

You should get a few quotes anytime you shop for an extended warranty to find the best option. Each company has different eligibility requirements, prices, and benefits, so it’s worth taking the extra time to shop around.

Endurance: Best Coverage

We think Endurance provides the best coverage compared to plans from other leading providers. The company offers six levels of protection that can cover a range of vehicles over 200,000 miles. Plus, each plan comes with 1 year free of Elite Benefits. Elite Benefits include roadside assistance, tire repair/replacement, total loss protection, collision discount, key fob replacement, and the Endurance mobile app.

Endurance has been covering vehicles for nearly two decades. The company has an “Excellent” rating from over 800 reviews on Trustpilot and a high customer rating from the BBB as well.

Get a free quote from Endurance to see how much you would pay for coverage.

CarShield: Best Budget Warranty

CarShield has covered more than one million vehicles, which shows how many drivers trust the company. It has been in business for more than 15 years and has been featured on CNN, HGTV, TBS, and others. We found that CarShield tends to be more affordable than many of its competitors.

CarShield offers six types of coverage plans. CarShield’s Diamond plan is comparable to a factory warranty, and the Aluminum plan is specifically designed for high-tech vehicles. CarShield has a rating of “Great” from over 10,000 reviews on Trustpilot. It’s the most popular provider we’ve researched by far.

Learn more about CarShield by getting a free quote for your vehicle.

Frequently Asked Questions

Get a Quote From Our Most Affordable Provider - CarShield

Plans as low as $99 per month