Liberty Auto Protection is an extended warranty provider that can pay for repairs to your vehicle after a mechanical breakdown. But with so many warranty companies to choose from, how do you know if Liberty is the best choice?

In this article, we’ll compare Liberty Auto Protection to a few of the best extended warranty companies to let you know what to look for in a provider. Anytime you shop for coverage, we recommend getting free quotes from multiple sources so you can find the best deal.

Top Extended Warranty Companies

Best Coverage
4.6/5
Get Price
Best for Used Cars
4.3/5
Get Price
Best Maintenance Benefits
4.2/5
Get Price
VIEW MORE
In This Review:

    About Liberty Auto Protection

    Liberty Auto Protection is a vehicle service contract provider based in New Jersey–not to be confused with Liberty Bell Auto Protect, which is another warranty company coincidentally based in New Jersey. The company offers plans directly on its website and through agents.

    Liberty Auto Protection plans are backed by Palmer Administrative Services, which also owns the trademark for Liberty Auto Protection. Palmer Administrative Services has a B rating from the Better Business Bureau (BBB). It has been in business for ten years.

    Liberty Auto Protection Pros

    Liberty Auto Protection Cons

    Six contract types

    No sample contracts

    Warranty company and administrator have close relationship

    No online quote system

    Choice of repair shop across the U.S. and Canada

    More complaints than reviews on the BBB

    Liberty Auto Protection Extended Warranty Coverage

    Liberty Auto Protection offers six plans that span a good range of coverage:

    • Elite Exclusionary: This plan covers any part unless it is specifically excluded. Some exclusions are cosmetic items, wear and tear, GPS systems, maintenance, alignments, and exhaust components.
    • Royal Select: This plan covers 13 major systems with optional coverage for five more, including SUV, high-tech, sliding door, and audio-visual packages.
    • Premier: This plan covers nine systems including the powertrain, water pump, transfer unit, electrical, and fuel systems.
    • Classic: This powertrain-plus plan covers six systems including the powertrain, electrical, air conditioning, and fuel systems.
    • Powertrain: This plan covers the engine, transmission, and drive axle.
    • Basic: This plan covers the engine only.

    Compared to other companies, these options are standard except for the engine-only basic plan. Most other extended auto warranty companies offer a powertrain plan as the lowest level.

    Liberty Auto Protection warranty plans include the following extra benefits:

    • Roadside assistance
    • Rental car reimbursement
    • Travel expense reimbursement (with most plans)

    The warranty company doesn’t provide sample contracts online, which is a red flag for transparency. It doesn’t give eligibility requirements in terms of mileage or age, either.

    Cost Of A Liberty Auto Protection Extended Warranty

    Liberty Auto Protection doesn’t publish costs online. In our research of top providers, we found plans normally cost between $350 and $650 per year of coverage. You can use that range as a guideline when receiving a quote from Liberty Auto Protection.

    Extended warranty costs are influenced by the state where you live and your car’s make, model, age, and mileage. Newer cars with fewer miles will generally have more affordable rates than cars with many miles.

    How Liberty Auto Protection Works

    Unlike most other extended warranty providers on the market today, Liberty Auto Protection doesn’t give quotes online. You’ll have to call the Liberty Auto Protection phone number to get a quote. The office for customer service and claims is only open during the week until 7 p.m. EST.

    All repairs need to be authorized before any work can be completed. The good thing is you can go to any licensed repair facility in the U.S. or Canada, and Liberty Auto Protection will pay the repair shop directly.

    Plans are transferable to secondary buyers. Transferring a warranty plan can add to the resale value of your car. Lastly, Liberty Auto Protection doesn’t have a cancellation policy listed online, so if you get a quote, be sure to ask about the cancellation policy.

    Liberty Auto Protection Reviews

    Of the more than 70 customer reviews for Palmer Administrative Services on the BBB, many are one-star reviews. In addition to that, there are about three times as many complaints. It’s never a good sign when the number of complaints outweigh the number of reviews.

    Many negative reviews aren’t actually from customers but from people who have been harassed by phone calls and aggressive warranty expiration notices from the company. Negative reviews from customers mention unpaid claims and poor customer service.

    Positive Liberty Auto Protection Reviews

    “It went smoothly. Not only did I get immediate help, I didn’t have to pay anything to the mechanic as the company said they would settle the bill themselves. I am a true believer in the worth and need for holding an auto protection plan.”
    – Paul S., BBB

    Negative Liberty Auto Protection Reviews

    “Horrible customer [service]. They will lie to you and give you the runaround. I have been without my car and no word on when it will be fixed. Stay away. I will be contacting someone about cancelling the policy.”
    – Jason M., BBB

    “They will only pay a capped amount for parts, not the dealer’s price. My car was in the shop for a drive axle and seal replacement and they clearly didn’t pay what’s required. They only paid a portion and I was on the hook for the remainder.”
    – Bernard S., BBB

    Bottom Line On Liberty Auto Protection: 3.0 Stars

    Liberty Auto Protection earned 3.0 stars from our review team for its extensive coverage offerings and good reviews on pricing. Whether or not the company fulfills its end of the bargain is another story, as shown by Liberty Auto Protection reviews.

    Reputation

    2.0

    Coverage

    4.0

    Price

    3.5

    Customer Experience

    2.0

    Overall Rating

    3.0

    Top Recommendations For Extended Car Warranties

    In our review of the nation’s best warranty providers, Endurance and CARCHEX earned the highest ratings for their strong coverage, competitive pricing, and smooth claims processes.

    Endurance: 4.6 Stars

    In our Endurance warranty review, we found that this company earns high praise from customers for its six coverage plans and low prices. Endurance is a direct provider that has been around for about 15 years. It administers its own plans so you don’t have to deal with a middleman when filing a claim.

    Here are a few things we like about Endurance:

    • Six levels of coverage: In addition to a basic powertrain warranty and a bumper-to-bumper warranty, you can find mid-level coverage and a plan that combines warranty coverage with regularly scheduled maintenance.
    • Endurance Elite membership: Each plan comes with one year free of Elite Benefits, which includes tire repairs and replacements, key fob replacement, total loss protection, collision discount, roadside assistance, and the Endurance mobile app.
    • Positive customer experience: Endurance has a rating of “Excellent” from over 3,300 reviews on Trustpilot. Positive reviews say Endurance representatives are courteous and they explain coverage thoroughly.

    Get a free quote from Endurance to see how much you would pay for coverage.

    CARCHEX: 4.3 Stars

    CARCHEX also stood out in our research for its long coverage terms and excellent reputation. CARCHEX can cover vehicles up to 250,000 miles, which makes it a great option for drivers with older cars. The company offers five levels of coverage and uses a few different administrators, which means each plan has different variations.

    Here are a few CARCHEX highlights:

    • Reputation: CARCHEX is endorsed by industry leaders like Kelley Blue Book, CARFAX, and Edmunds.com. It also has an A+ rating from the BBB.
    • Transparency: You can read different sample contracts for each CARCHEX plan on its website to know exactly what’s covered. The company gets many positive reviews, but it doesn’t try to hide negative ones, either. Instead, customer service representatives respond to offer help and issue refunds when necessary.
    • Price: The CARCHEX No-Haggle, Low-Price, Everyday GuaranteeTM means you’ll always get the lowest price available when you get a quote. This sets CARCHEX apart from other providers that only offer discounts in certain situations.

    Learn more about CARCHEX by getting a free quote for your vehicle.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    • What is an auto protection plan?

      An auto protection plan is also known as an extended warranty or vehicle service contract. Protection plans can be offered by manufacturers, dealers, or third-party providers. They cover repairs after mechanical breakdowns and generally exclude damage from accidents, lack of maintenance, and normal wear and tear.

    • Are vehicle protection plans worth it?

      If you don’t want to deal with auto repairs, a vehicle protection plan can be worth it. It’s a good idea to have a protection plan if you don’t have a sizable emergency fund saved up, as well. A single car repair could cost $1,000 or more, and many drivers would rather make a small monthly payment instead.

      On the other hand, you might not need one if you’re capable of covering unexpected repairs on your own.

    • Who has the best auto extended warranty?

      The best auto extended warranty ultimately depends on your vehicle and what you’re looking for, but some providers are better than others. Our team of experts rated Endurance, CARCHEX, and CarShield highly.