Mike is totally over this whole winter thing. He loves the beach and chases storms, so what he’s looking for a cheap 4x4 just in time for summer. It just needs to take him and his gear through the sand. What car should he buy?

(Welcome back to What Car Should You Buy? Where we give real people real advice about buying cars. Do you want us to help you find a car? Submit your story on our form.)

Here is the scenario:

I live on Eastern Long Island and have traditionally owned 2-3 cars at a time, always including a 4WD beach car. Until last year, my corral consisted of a BMW X5, a 1997 Jeep Wrangler and a Chrysler 300 AWD. I’ve owned G-Wagens, Volvos, Mercedes-Benzes, VWs, Porsches, you name it. Today, in an effort to curb expenses, I own and drive one car, a 2017 Prius Prime that I, surprisingly, love! It’s great on the road, averaging over 100 mpg through 21,000 miles and I feel like I’m being a good citizen. But! The Prime is no beach wagon, so I need some suggestions

I’m looking for a 4WD beach wagon, (it doesn’t actually have to be a wagon. SUV, truck, or whatever) for under $3500 so I don’t need collision insurance and I can get back on the beach. Summer’s coming!

Advertisement

Quick Facts:

Budget: up to $3500

Daily Driver: Not really

Location: Long Island

Wants: Cheap, 4x4, good for the beach

Doesn’t want: Something that will get stuck

Expert 1: Tom McParland - Greetings From The Jersey Shore

Advertisement

Mike, I was so excited to take this case because like you, I’m a beach bum. When I was in high school, I would obsess over incoming storms and what the waves would be like on a given day. I also used the word “gnarly.” Excessively.

I wanted so badly to recommend a Jeep Grand Wagoneer because I saw one as a kid in an awesome teal blue with a matching surfboard and I thought that was the coolest surfer car ever. Unfortunately, unless you are David Tracy and luck out with some cheap Wagoner that needs a lot of work, the good ones are mad expensive.

You’ll have to settle for the next best thing: the tried and true XJ Cherokee. They are cheap, durable, have a legit four-wheel drive system and, as David can testify, a little rust here and there just gives them some extra character.

Advertisement

Here is a two-door not far from you that looks clean... enough.

Expert 2: Raphael Orlove - Loves Forgotten Cars

Advertisement

Honestly, it’s hard to find any faults in Tom’s argument. Even I admit that if you’re looking for something like a Jeep...just buy a Jeep. But! The car world is full of interesting cars, cars that should not be ignored. Also there are Baja Bugs, but you want to be driving a car, not spending all weekend trying to figure out how you’re going to change your wheel bearings in a parking lot.

It is with this in mind that I will recommend the wonderful Dodge Raider, a car that everyone forgets existed.

Back in the day Chrysler brought over re-badged Mitsubishis to America as captive imports. We usually think of how the Mitsubishi 3000GT became the Dodge Stealth or how the Mitsubishi Eclipse became the Eagle Talon, but it’s easy to gloss over the Mitsubishi Montero/Pajero that became the Dodge Raider. Thankfully, so does the used car market, and a decent condition old-school truck like this one for $2200 is still well within your budget.

Advertisement

Expert 3: Patrick George - Baja Or Die

When you say you need a cheap, reliable four- or all-wheel drive car for whatever reason, my mind always goes to older Subarus. They’re cheap, reliable (for the most part, but not like Honda-level invincible) and tough as nails. I nearly suggested an Outback or a Forester for this task. Those are plentiful on Craigslist and generally cheap.

Advertisement

But! It was suggested to me that maybe another Subaru is better at hauling your beach crap, and more interesting: the Baja trucklet of the 2000s. Wouldn’t that be fun and different? These things are pretty hardy, plus they combine all the good stuff about Subarus with all the utility of a small truck. Hell, they should bring them back. The Baja would probably sell well in the current market.

Here’s a 2003 non-turbo model for sale in New Hampshire for just $3,200. Nice price.

Expert 4: David Tracy - This Is Not A Jeep

Unfortunately, my editors have banned me from recommending Jeeps in What Car Should You Buy articles. That’s a damn shame, because there are few vehicles on this earth as beach-worthy as a Willys Station Wagon.

Advertisement

But no matter, because in a stroke of utter genius, I’ve found a workaround to this totally unfair rule: the Ford Rural.

Oh yes, it’s totally a Ford (and not a Jeep). Offered in Brazil in the late ’60s until the late ’70s, the Ford (and not a Jeep) Rural was based on the Willys Wagon platform, with the Blue Oval having purchased the Toledo-based company’s Brazil plant in 1967 (despite those bones, that tailgate, as shown above, says Ford, making this very much not a Jeep).

The Rural is pretty much everything you need, Mike. It’s got tons of room, it’s four-wheel drive, and parts are easy to find since they’re basically Jeep (but also, very much not Jeep) parts. Can you find one for under $3,500? Probably not.

Advertisement

(You can, however, find an okay-shape Willys Wagon for that price, but I’m not allowed to mention that. So good luck finding the Ford Rural for under $3,500. You can blame my editors.)