• Jalopnik
  • spy-photos
  • jalopnik-reviews
  • Profile logout login

#v8#msg7735topicseen

Jalopnik

Share Cancel
   
Upload an image | Add an image URL
×

logging in
  • FAQ. Include # before tag:
  • #offtopic,
  • #tips,
  • #spyphotos,
  • etc.

Detroit, 3:08 PM
Sat Dec 5
16 posts in the last 24 hours

Contact

Tip your editors:

Editor-in-Chief:
Ray Wert | | AIM

Road Test Editor:
Wes Siler |

Weekend Editor:
Murilee Martin |

Associate Editor - Houston:

Associate Editor - Detroit:

Editor-at-Large:

Contributors:

John Krewson |

Follow Jalopnik on:
Facebook
Twitter

SUBSCRIBE TO Jalopnik RSS

New: Breaking news and daily top stories via email
1753 Subscribers
Jalopnik
  • Your version of Internet Explorer is not supported. Please upgrade to the most recent version in order to view comments.

    Dsmvwl  Admin  Promote to frontpage Approve user Ban user ×
    Image of ozyran ozyran
    11/22/09

    In reply to Engine Of The Day: BMW OHV V8
    Chevrolet *had* a prehistoric V8?

    Had.

    Right.
     Reply
    ozyran was starred ozyran was unstarred
    Image of Muscles Marinara Muscles Marinara
    11/22/09

    @ozyran: Yes... a prehistoric pushrod V8 that, in N/A form, happens to make 500+HP, 470 lb/ft of torque, and yet amazingly achieves 26+ mpg highway in the Corvette Z06.
     Reply
    tonyola promoted this comment Muscles Marinara was starred Muscles Marinara was unstarred
    Image of tonyola tonyola
    11/22/09

    @Muscles Marinara: Not to mention that it's lighter and far more compact than many smaller-displacement, less powerful engines.
     Reply
    tonyola was starred tonyola was unstarred
    Image of Muscles Marinara Muscles Marinara
    11/23/09


    @tonyola:
    Exactly. Obviously there is no equivalent picture for chevy engines, but this picture illustrates one pretty big advantage small-block pushrod engines have over their OHC counterparts. Hmm... I wonder which one weighs more? And if the performance and efficiency numbers GM gets out of their pushrods keep getting better, as they most certainly will, they'd be crazy to switch to an OHC design, which, news flash people, isn't exactly the pinnacle of "new" technology - DOHCs have been around for almost a century.
     Reply
    Muscles Marinara was starred Muscles Marinara was unstarred
    Image of ozyran ozyran
    11/23/09

    @Muscles Marinara: You do realize that it gets 26+ mpg (on the highway cruising in 6th gear on level ground without a headwind or a heavy foot) in the Corvette solely based on the fact that it's pushing around a 3100-lb chassis that's designed for aerodynamics, right?

    You can tout the "advantages" of the pushrod design but it does have its limitations. If the 6.2L V8 under the hood of the Z06 is so great, then why does Ferrari's 4.3L manage to come in at 483 hp without supercharging? Undoubtedly, the 4.3L V8 is smaller, more compact, and lighter than the 6.2L V8 under the hood of the Vette. Oh, and it *does* utilize OHC design, something Ferrari has been utilizing successfully since the mid '60s. Shortly after the design and implementation of OHC engines in the Ferrari race cars, they were already working on a 5 valve design in their cylinder heads. True, Ford came back and bit Ferrari, quite hard. But that was with a 427 using what? An overhead cam design.

    The only reason to stick with pushrods is cost. It's the question of, "Why fix it? It's not broke."

    Sure, the Corvette Z06 is "only" $75,000.00. given the quality of the interior materials and the archaic engine architecture GM is using, I'd say you're getting what you pay for.

    #tips
     Reply
    tonyola promoted this comment Edited by ozyran at 11/23/09 12:51 AM ozyran was starred ozyran was unstarred
    Image of tonyola tonyola
    11/23/09

    @ozyran: You're making the mistake of equating piston volume displacement with the physical size and weight of the engine. The 7.0-liter Corvette LS7 weighs 458 pounds. The 5.0-liter BMW M5 engine weighs 529 pounds. The Corvette engine, as I said in a previous post, is very light and compact for its size and power. The 4.3 Ferrari engine is not "undoubtedly" smaller and lighter than the 'Vette engine - back up your claim with numbers. If you can do that, we'll accept your statement.

    Also, the 427 used in the GT40 was a pushrod. The SOHC 427 was intended to be a NASCAR engine but it was never permitted to run, so it ended up in drag racers. It was NOT used in the GT40.

    Check your facts and come back to play when you think you're ready.
     Reply
    Edited by tonyola at 11/23/09 1:28 AM tonyola was starred tonyola was unstarred
    Image of Brybe Brybe
    11/23/09

    @Muscles Marinara: Most of the decent gas mileage can be attributed to the aerodynamics and weight of the corvette. But yes, still one of my favorite engines.
     Reply
    tonyola promoted this comment Brybe was starred Brybe was unstarred
    Image of tonyola tonyola
    11/23/09

    @Brybe: Just for grins, here are the city/highway mileage ratings for some sports cars from the 2010 EPA Guide. The Chevy does pretty damn well compared to other largish sports cars. This should kill the notion that large-displacement engines are always inefficient.

    AUDI R8
    A-S6 4.2/8 13/18
    M-6 4.2/8 12/19
    AM6 5.2/10 13/20
    M-6 5.2/10 12/20

    CHEVROLET Corvette
    A-S6 6.2/8 15/25
    M-6 6.2/8 16/26
    M-6 6.2/8 14/20
    M-6 7.0/8 15/24

    FERRARI 599 GTB Fiorano
    AM6 5.7/12 11/15
    M-6 5.7/12 11/15

    LAMBORGHINI
    Gallardo Coupe
    AM6 5.2/10 14/20
    M-6 5.2/10 12/20
    Murcielago
    AM6 6.5/12 9/14
    M-6 6.5/12 8/13

    MASERATI GranTurismo
    A-6 4.2/8 12/19
    A-6 4.7/8 12/19

    NISSAN GT-R
    AM6 3.8/6 16/21
     Reply
    Edited by tonyola at 11/23/09 6:54 AM tonyola was starred tonyola was unstarred
    Image of Brybe Brybe
    11/23/09

    @tonyola: No doubt but it's not really the engine. I also forgot to mention the ridiculous 6th gear ratio which is a huge factor. Most cars don't have a gear that is useless outside of highway gearing.

    And don't get me wrong, LSx series engines are my favorite.
    #tips
     Reply
    Brybe was starred Brybe was unstarred
    Image of brandegee brandegee
    11/23/09

    @tonyola: The new OHVs do very well, but only because Chevy managed to build variable valve timing into the block.

    It's not really about fuel consumption. It's about the limitations on pushrod engines. Low rev limits, and very little space for electronic valve control are both potential killers.

    If you want a reason why we don't see more OHVs from GM, just compare Chevy's line of pushrod V6s to the DOHC units.
     Reply
    brandegee was starred brandegee was unstarred
    Image of Mobius Mobius
    11/22/09

    In reply to Engine Of The Day: BMW OHV V8
    And they also used to have horse-cart suspension, didn't they?

    Oh, and GM and Ford...
     Reply
    Mobius was starred Mobius was unstarred
    Image of HurtsSoGood HurtsSoGood
    11/22/09

    In reply to Engine Of The Day: The Very First Chevrolet V8
    FTFA:

    Advanced in design, the 1917 V-8 had a central camshaft operating vertical overhead valves in each bank, a counterweighted crankshaft, and detachable crossflow cylinder heads. Displacing 288 cubic inches and breathing through a Zenith two-barrel carburetor, it developed 55 horsepower at 2,700 rpm, running on 4.75:1 compression.

    This is probably because gasoline had an octane rating in the mid-40s in those days. 4.75:1 was probably pushing it, and 55 HP was about as good as it got for that size engine during World War I.
     Reply
    HurtsSoGood was starred HurtsSoGood was unstarred
    Image of tonyola tonyola
    11/22/09

    In reply to Engine Of The Day: BMW OHV V8

    BMW had also intended to use the V8 in a top-line limousine called the 505. There is a story that BMW showed German Chancellor Adenauer a prototype of the limousine to try to woo him away from his Mercedes 300. The Chancellor's hat got knocked off as he entered the rear seat. At that moment, BMW knew they lost their chance and immediately killed off the 505 program.
     Reply
    tonyola was starred tonyola was unstarred
    Image of brandegee brandegee
    11/23/09

    @tonyola: Cool, thanks for the story. I had no idea about the 505. Proves that BMW was gunning for M-B's market share pretty early on.
     Reply
    brandegee was starred brandegee was unstarred
    Image of CurlyQLink CurlyQLink
    11/22/09

    In reply to Engine Of The Day: BMW OHV V8
    My brother had a 1959 502 sedan that he bought used in the late 60's. It was probably a serviceman's car brought back home from Europe. The car was black and stodgy but solid and supremely smooth. The engine however was a work of art with beautiful aluminum castings everywhere. I think the version in his car made 130-140hp and powered through a four speed on the column. He claimed it would do 70 in 2nd gear. Autobahn gearing for sure. He couldn't find brake parts for it so traded for a 190SL with bad carbs. Of the two I'd go for the 502.
     Reply
    Six Flags Over Tomsk promoted this comment CurlyQLink was starred CurlyQLink was unstarred
    Image of FantozziUgo FantozziUgo
    11/22/09

    In reply to Engine Of The Day: BMW OHV V8

    My engine of the day is the Alfa Romeo Montreal 230 hp, 1970 dry sump V8...
     Reply
    UDMan promoted this comment FantozziUgo was starred FantozziUgo was unstarred
    Image of UDMan UDMan
    11/22/09

    @FantozziUgo: This is suppose to be Murilee's Engine of the Day Feature, not whatever engine you want to show off for the day.

    That being said, I love the Montreal V-8.
     Reply
    UDMan was starred UDMan was unstarred
    Image of LandofMinos, cast thou evil bum dragger to thy scrapyard LandofMinos, cast thou evil bum dragger to thy scrapyard
    11/22/09

    In reply to Engine Of The Day: BMW OHV V8
    WOW! With this sort of cutting edge technology, BMW could play NASCAR.

    I wonder why they don't?
     Reply
    Edited by LandofMinos, cast thou evil bum dragger to thy scrapyard at 11/22/09 5:55 PM LandofMinos, cast thou evil bum dragger to thy scrapyard was starred LandofMinos, cast thou evil bum dragger to thy scrapyard was unstarred
    Image of jewce is fueled by sour gummy worms jewce is fueled by sour gummy worms
    11/22/09

    @LandofMinos, cast thou evil bum dragger to thy scrapyard: LMFAOSHMFMBIAIHTHIASTRI
     Reply
    LandofMinos, cast thou evil bum dragger to thy scrapyard promoted this comment jewce is fueled by sour gummy worms was starred jewce is fueled by sour gummy worms was unstarred
    Image of LandofMinos, cast thou evil bum dragger to thy scrapyard LandofMinos, cast thou evil bum dragger to thy scrapyard
    11/22/09

    @jewce is fueled by sour gummy worms: Well I got the first five letters, may I please have the rest in sentence form?
     Reply
    LandofMinos, cast thou evil bum dragger to thy scrapyard was starred LandofMinos, cast thou evil bum dragger to thy scrapyard was unstarred
    Image of jewce is fueled by sour gummy worms jewce is fueled by sour gummy worms
    11/23/09

    @LandofMinos, cast thou evil bum dragger to thy scrapyard: Laughing my f ass off so hard my fecal matter becomes impacted and I have to have invasive anal surgery to remove it.

    #tips
     Reply
    jewce is fueled by sour gummy worms was starred jewce is fueled by sour gummy worms was unstarred
    Image of Six Flags Over Tomsk Six Flags Over Tomsk
    11/22/09

    In reply to Engine Of The Day: BMW OHV V8
    Step 1: Cram this engine into a Dixi
    Step 2: Chop top of and remove fenders from said Dixi
    Step 3: ?
    Step 4: Profit!
     Reply
    Six Flags Over Tomsk was starred Six Flags Over Tomsk was unstarred
    Image of Turboner Turboner
    11/21/09

    In reply to 2011 Hyundai Genesis: "Tau" V8 Gets A 10 HP Bump
    I'm sure the irridium spark plugs had so much to do with it.
     Reply
    Turboner was starred Turboner was unstarred
    Image of Ryan K. Light Ryan K. Light
    11/20/09

    In reply to 2011 Hyundai Genesis: "Tau" V8 Gets A 10 HP Bump
    Put this in the coupe asap and i will buy 2!
     Reply
    philibuster promoted this comment Ryan K. Light was starred Ryan K. Light was unstarred
    Image of philibuster philibuster
    11/21/09

    @Ryan K. Light: Hey, Pauljones, this guy just proved your point.
     Reply
    philibuster was starred philibuster was unstarred
    Image of If FromaBuick6 has to watch one more Chevy commercial, he's going to punch Howie Long in the face If FromaBuick6 has to watch one more Chevy commercial, he's going to punch Howie Long in the face
    11/20/09

    In reply to 2011 Hyundai Genesis: "Tau" V8 Gets A 10 HP Bump
    Wow, because nobody has ever found a way to squeeze less than half a dozen horsepower from an engine by tinkering with the manifolds before.
     Reply
    If FromaBuick6 has to watch one more Chevy commercial, he's going to punch Howie Long in the face was starred If FromaBuick6 has to watch one more Chevy commercial, he's going to punch Howie Long in the face was unstarred
    Image of pauljones pauljones
    11/20/09

    In reply to 2011 Hyundai Genesis: "Tau" V8 Gets A 10 HP Bump
    I still have a hard time believing that they didn't design the Genesis coupe big enough to accept the Tau V8.
     Reply
    pauljones was starred pauljones was unstarred
    Image of PowerTryp is holding a Fiesta party. PowerTryp is holding a Fiesta party.
    11/20/09

    @pauljones: Oh they did, you just have to put it in the back.

    [jalopnik.com]
     Reply
    pauljones promoted this comment PowerTryp is holding a Fiesta party. was starred PowerTryp is holding a Fiesta party. was unstarred
    Image of pauljones pauljones
    11/20/09

    @PowerTryp, Starless wonder.: Yeah, no. That doesn't qualify.

    Hyundai should have designed the coupe's engine bay to accept the Tau V8. Had they done so from the beginning, I don't think it would have cost them too much extra money, and it would give them and aftermarket tuners a lot more flexibility with the platform.

    #tips
     Reply
    pauljones was starred pauljones was unstarred
    Image of PowerTryp is holding a Fiesta party. PowerTryp is holding a Fiesta party.
    11/20/09

    @pauljones: I thought it was a good joke.

    The whole problem is that they failed to use the same platform for the two cars that share a name, so I wouldn't doubt that you could stuff the Tau V8 in the front of a Coupe but when your V6 already makes 300 HP then whats the point especially when the V6 weighs less.
     Reply
    PowerTryp is holding a Fiesta party. was starred PowerTryp is holding a Fiesta party. was unstarred
    Image of pauljones pauljones
    11/20/09

    @PowerTryp, Starless wonder.: Platform growth potential.

    The Camaro just came out, and the base model has an engine just as powerful as the high-end Genesis coupe (although the Camaro is actually a tenth of a second or two slower due to its weight, though it get better mileage), and the Camaro SS leaves the Genesis in the dust.

    The 2011 Mustang will have a base engine more powerful than the Genesis coupe's premium engine, and won't have the same weight disadvantage that the Camaro has. And the 2011 Mustang GT? It, too, will leave the Genesis coupe in a cloud of dust and tire smoke.

    Granted, the base price for the highest Genesis coupe trim line undercuts the base Camaro SS and Mustang GT price by a grand or two, but for that extra grand or two, you get a hell of a lot.

    Where the Genesis coupe makes the least sense is stacked up against the base models of the 2010 Camaro and the 2011 Mustang, which are at the least it's peer in power, get better mileage, and are more refined than the Genesis coupe; all for a price that is in the same ballpark of a base, 4-cyl Genesis coupe.

    Had Hyundai designed a little more growth potential into the Genesis coupe platform by designing it to accept the Tau V8, they could have made the platform more competitive in a broader field.

    #tips
     Reply
    pauljones was starred pauljones was unstarred
    Image of GreenN_Gold GreenN_Gold
    11/20/09

    @pauljones: Don't expect Hyundai to cow tao to you whims by designing the coupe to accomodate the big 'ol V8 cow Tau.
     Reply
    GreenN_Gold was starred GreenN_Gold was unstarred
    Image of dal20402 dal20402
    11/20/09

    @PowerTryp, Starless wonder.: Good point on the weight. Does anyone know the weights of the 3.8 and the Tau?

    The Genesis Coupe is a bit smaller than its domestic competition. I'm thinking a V8 model would be very front-heavy.
     Reply
    pauljones promoted this comment dal20402 was starred dal20402 was unstarred
    Image of pauljones pauljones
    11/20/09

    @dal20402: I've been trying to find the weight and dimensions of the Genesis engines, but, ironically, those seem to be the only bits of information I can't find about them.
     Reply
    pauljones was starred pauljones was unstarred
    Image of alowishus wants to run a Saab Sonett III at LeMons alowishus wants to run a Saab Sonett III at LeMons
    11/20/09

    @pauljones: Somehow I don't think the Genesis Coupe is competing with big 'Merican muscle cars.
     Reply
    pauljones promoted this comment alowishus wants to run a Saab Sonett III at LeMons was starred alowishus wants to run a Saab Sonett III at LeMons was unstarred
    Image of pauljones pauljones
    11/20/09

    @alowishus wants to run a Saab Sonett III at LeMons: It isn't? Then what was it that was Hyundai's rationale for bringing the Genesis coupe to the market?

    @Mixtronic: So can the Camaro and the Mustang. The Challenger? Well, not quite as well, but it's far from scary.
     Reply
    pauljones was starred pauljones was unstarred
    Image of alowishus wants to run a Saab Sonett III at LeMons alowishus wants to run a Saab Sonett III at LeMons
    11/21/09

    @pauljones: Yeah yeah yeah, I know they went and slapped the mustang and all that. But seriously, show me a guy who wants to buy a Mustang who's going to be swayed by a Genesis. My point being that in the real world, the yokels who want muscle cars won't be drawn to the the Genesis. It'll be young moderately successful guys and the JDM set.

    #tips
     Reply
    alowishus wants to run a Saab Sonett III at LeMons was starred alowishus wants to run a Saab Sonett III at LeMons was unstarred
    Image of pauljones pauljones
    11/21/09

    @alowishus wants to run a Saab Sonett III at LeMons: You make a fair point from the standpoint that a Mustang guy is a Mustang guy is a Mustang guy.

    But the truth is, the majority of people in the non-premium sporty, RWD coupe market (in which the Genesis, Mustang, Camaro, Challenger, 370Z, and RX-8 compete) aren't necessarily Mustang people. They are people out to buy a car in that class, and while they may have a short list, they are likely to consider alternatives based on the deals they can get and other similar criteria.

    So yes, the Genesis does indeed compete with the Mustang.

    #tips
     Reply
    pauljones was starred pauljones was unstarred
    Image of Turboner Turboner
    10/14/09

    In reply to Alfa Romeo Developing 3.0-Liter Twin-Turbo V8, Could Come Stateside
    LIVO just kicked in, YO!
     Reply
    Turboner was starred Turboner was unstarred
    Image of Pessimippopotamus Pessimippopotamus
    10/14/09

    In reply to Alfa Romeo Developing 3.0-Liter Twin-Turbo V8, Could Come Stateside
    Hooray for small displacement V8s!

    Alfa needs to make the spiritual successor to the Thema 8.32 ASAP and I'll rob a bank for it. Or just plain rob the car!
     Reply
    Pessimippopotamus was starred Pessimippopotamus was unstarred
    Image of Schm, enjoying his first desert winter. . Schm, enjoying his first desert winter. .
    10/14/09

    In reply to Alfa Romeo Developing 3.0-Liter Twin-Turbo V8, Could Come Stateside
    "Fiat is basing the 166, the sedan this image is being developed for, around the next-gen 300C. "

    By "image," I take it you mean "engine."

    Also, Alfa denies it.

    [www.autoblog.com]
     Reply
    Edited by Schm, enjoying his first desert winter. . at 10/14/09 2:38 PM Schm, enjoying his first desert winter. . was starred Schm, enjoying his first desert winter. . was unstarred
    Earlier discussions Other discussions Show all discussions Show featured discussions only Start a new discussion

Login

Enter your username and password.

Please enter a username.
Please enter your password.
logging in
Login via Facebook | Sign Up | Forgot Password?

Reset Password

Please enter your email address to have your password reset.

Please enter your email address.
Please enter a valid email address.
requesting password reset

Register

Registering will give you a user profile and the ability to add other users as friends. To become a commenter, however, you need to audition.

Want to know more? Consult the Comment FAQ and legal terms.

Please enter a username.
Please enter a password.
Please confirm your password.
Passwords are not identical.
Please enter a valid email address.
registration sent, waiting for reply

Submit Your Comment

You don't need to login to comment. Just enter your email address below.

See how your address will be displayed in the Comment FAQ.

Please enter a valid email address.
Please enter a valid email address.
logging in

Login with your Facebook or Jalopnik account.

Sign up here.



  • Archives
  • About
  • Advertising
  • Legal
  • Help
  • Report a Bug
  • FAQ
Original material is licensed under a Creative Commons License permitting non-commercial sharing with attribution.