Sounds like fraud, or misidentification. Even a burnt- out shell of a TVR should be worth more than $4500. A friend of mine was a garbage man in the early 80's, when the steel mills here in Pittsburgh were shutting down. He had several guys give him $50 to throw their nearly new Harleys into the crusher, so they could report them stolen and get out of the payments.
So either a lot of fraud happened during cash 4 clunkers or a lot of people can't type and entered information wrong.
I refuse to believe that someone would happily trade in their 97 Continental R or 06 A4 Cabriolet for a max of $4500, i truly don't think anyone with those cars is that stupid.
So either someone took there severly mashed up Bentley (Which if it was worth less than $4500 probably wasn't drivable and therefore not eligible) and somehow got the dealership to agree to a trade or someone has entered something wrong on a computer and meant to type 2wd Explorer and failed miserably.
You would hope that someone somewhere looked at this list and went eh??? and will investigate what happened but i doubt it.........
I mean to say I lack faith in the intelligence of humanity is like saying the Pacific Ocean is damp, but even I'm doubtful anyone could be that monumentally stupid.
If we believe the soul is too beautiful to perish, then we must remember that the lost live on. If moving on to a greater knowledge, they have had their freedom and perspective increased, and can find a place where the roads have been left to wind, and the trees left to overhang.
/I wish it was cold, I wish I could see the stars.
Alright, I call BS here, at least at some level. Car dealerships are businesses and as such would never sell a car for a tenth of its value. Even if they only gave the idiot non-human owner $4500 for it, they could have easily turned around and sold the car for whatever price they want. It's easier than ever to determine a ballpark value for a car. A monkey can read the back of the car and then check kbb.com. Hell, a dealership in Philly decided to take a loss with a late 80's Caprice because it had only 37,000 miles and was in perfect condition.
So what is happening with this list then? Fraud? Maybe, even probably. Just a cursory look at the list reveals that supposedly 2 2002 BMW (E39) 525i's were traded in under the program. It doesn't even qualify!!!!! Either that's the product of fraud, or the list is just dead wrong. Maybe it's denial, but I'm not going to buy that a GNX was put to death under C4C. The LaForza, Typhoon, 850i, and Excalibur are believable in high-mileage thrashed condition. Still very sad, though.
I hereby mourn these and all other Jalop-worthy cars put to death under C4C. This included a total in the hundreds of mid-90's B-bodies, BMW M's, Audi S series cars, Camaros, Vettes, Foxes, etc etc.
@gman1023: If the dealership submitted the car to the Gov't as a C4C vehicle, when they had no choice (legally, anyway) but to process the car as per the guidelines... there's no rule, however, that stated that if a customer offered a trade-in that they HAD to accept it under C4C... a smart dealer could always have said: "Tellya, what, pal - I'll give you $500 extra for that Aston Martin if we do it as a straight trade/no clunkers.", and they would have been idiots not to do so.
But, then again, there are idiots in the world, as is evidenced by this entire thread/article, assuming it's all true.
@HoonThatFerrari: Exactly. Or, they could even pay the owner just $4500 and just "forget" to submit all of the necessary paperwork.
And yes, heartless idiots, I might add. The thought of a clunkerized Typhoon sickens me. Even if it does burn more oil than gasoline and has 200,000 miles.
@Maymar: No argument from me. Excaliburs are some of the gaudiest pieces of garbage. And as often as not, it seems that the value is in line for C4C anyway. No loss there.
You missed the 1989 Pontiac Turbo Trans Am which was also clunkered according to the list linked by others.
I blame the owners less (who knows maybe these were cars that were dumped on them by deceased loved ones, or some other weird situation) but the dealers more. I mean think about it when they take a trade in that they cant sell (anything older than like 6 or 7 years old most dealers don't put on the lot) they send it to auction. If the dealer had half a brain they would say "sure we will give you $4500" and instead of CFCing the car they would send it out to auction where any of these rides would bring twice that minimum.
The Continental R seems to be worth at least $50k, via ebay.
I would like to think some of these cars had significant body damage, plus maybe a mostly blown engine, transmission, or both. Maybe a salvage title to boot.
Car salesmen are crafty if not rocket scientists. I would assume most of these cars would have had a better offer than CFC from a dealership. What car dealership would leave at least $45k on the table?
@UDMan: How can 3 2007 Acadias be C4C eligible? How in the hell does a car see $25,500 in depreciation in two years or less? (I assume base MSRP ~$30k) I don't see how they got those in.
@UDMan:
The new cars in some ways make the biggest indictment of our consumerist, throw-away society, which, despite the best efforts of Pelosi and co to paint this as pro-environment, was what this bill was really about. I've already expressed how I feel about the GNX, so I won't go there... How can anyone in their right mind think that a 3-year old Z-car or a 1 year-old Mustang or 300C is something you throw out like toilet paper when you get tired of it? And how can trading that car in for another new car to make payments on make any kind of financial sense? These people have the same kind of screwed-up mindset as the d-bags who got us into this mess with the subprime loans and defaulting on their mortgages because they didn't feel like paying anymore and what not... the answer to every problem for them is running from any kind of responsibility.
@skulldriveshaft picasaweb and youtube: Not only that but generally their mileage rating is much too high to qualify. The Tracker would probably wind up under the line.
I used to go by the axiom that people are generally smart, but sometimes act stupidly.
The longer I live the more I realize that people are just idiots. I think this has something to do with my theory that Darwin was wrong and the opposite is true.
The people who clunkered 2,3,7, & 8 need to have their toenails and teeth pulled off with pliers before having hot pokers jammed into every orifice simultaneously.
09/25/09
09/23/09
09/23/09
I refuse to believe that someone would happily trade in their 97 Continental R or 06 A4 Cabriolet for a max of $4500, i truly don't think anyone with those cars is that stupid.
So either someone took there severly mashed up Bentley (Which if it was worth less than $4500 probably wasn't drivable and therefore not eligible) and somehow got the dealership to agree to a trade or someone has entered something wrong on a computer and meant to type 2wd Explorer and failed miserably.
You would hope that someone somewhere looked at this list and went eh??? and will investigate what happened but i doubt it.........
09/23/09
I mean to say I lack faith in the intelligence of humanity is like saying the Pacific Ocean is damp, but even I'm doubtful anyone could be that monumentally stupid.
09/23/09
/I wish it was cold, I wish I could see the stars.
09/23/09
So what is happening with this list then? Fraud? Maybe, even probably. Just a cursory look at the list reveals that supposedly 2 2002 BMW (E39) 525i's were traded in under the program. It doesn't even qualify!!!!! Either that's the product of fraud, or the list is just dead wrong. Maybe it's denial, but I'm not going to buy that a GNX was put to death under C4C. The LaForza, Typhoon, 850i, and Excalibur are believable in high-mileage thrashed condition. Still very sad, though.
I hereby mourn these and all other Jalop-worthy cars put to death under C4C. This included a total in the hundreds of mid-90's B-bodies, BMW M's, Audi S series cars, Camaros, Vettes, Foxes, etc etc.
09/23/09
But, then again, there are idiots in the world, as is evidenced by this entire thread/article, assuming it's all true.
09/23/09
09/23/09
And yes, heartless idiots, I might add. The thought of a clunkerized Typhoon sickens me. Even if it does burn more oil than gasoline and has 200,000 miles.
09/23/09
09/23/09
I blame the owners less (who knows maybe these were cars that were dumped on them by deceased loved ones, or some other weird situation) but the dealers more. I mean think about it when they take a trade in that they cant sell (anything older than like 6 or 7 years old most dealers don't put on the lot) they send it to auction. If the dealer had half a brain they would say "sure we will give you $4500" and instead of CFCing the car they would send it out to auction where any of these rides would bring twice that minimum.
I can't even fathom the stupidity!
09/23/09
I would like to think some of these cars had significant body damage, plus maybe a mostly blown engine, transmission, or both. Maybe a salvage title to boot.
Car salesmen are crafty if not rocket scientists. I would assume most of these cars would have had a better offer than CFC from a dealership. What car dealership would leave at least $45k on the table?
There are stories behind these sales.
09/23/09
- 3 Alfa Romeo Milanos
- Over 50 AMC Eagles
- 6 1984 - 1991 Audi Coupe GT and Quattro
- 4 Audi S4's and 4 S6's
- 45 BMW 6 Series
- 1 M3, 1 M5, and 1 Z3
- 1 CCC Engineering Duntov GT
- 52 Allantes
- A Few 1994 - 96 Impala SS
- at least 132 Corvettes
- at least 200 El Caminos
- 17 Chrysler Conquests (Mitsubishi Starion)
- 39 TC By Masarati
- 210 Stealths
- 1 Courier Pickup
- 24 Lightnings
- 107 Ford Taurus SHO
- 3 2007 GMC Acadias
- 15 Isuzu Vehicross
- Jaguars.... that count astounds
- 9 Jaguar XJR
- 2 XK8, 23 XJS, 26 XJS Cvt,
- A Boatload of Grand Wagoneers, and J10/20 Pickups
- 3 Laforzas
- You don't want to now the number of RX-7 and RX-8's
- 26 Merkur Scorpios, 21 XR4Ti's
- 20 Mitsubishi 3000 GT Spyders
- 5 Starions
- 1 2006 350Z Roadster
- 1 2006 Altima Coupe
- 22 Peugeots
- 61 Fieros
- 1 TVR 280i
- 310 Toyota Supras
I Think that's enough to think over
09/23/09
09/23/09
09/23/09
09/23/09
09/24/09
The new cars in some ways make the biggest indictment of our consumerist, throw-away society, which, despite the best efforts of Pelosi and co to paint this as pro-environment, was what this bill was really about. I've already expressed how I feel about the GNX, so I won't go there... How can anyone in their right mind think that a 3-year old Z-car or a 1 year-old Mustang or 300C is something you throw out like toilet paper when you get tired of it? And how can trading that car in for another new car to make payments on make any kind of financial sense? These people have the same kind of screwed-up mindset as the d-bags who got us into this mess with the subprime loans and defaulting on their mortgages because they didn't feel like paying anymore and what not... the answer to every problem for them is running from any kind of responsibility.
09/24/09
09/25/09
09/23/09
09/24/09
09/25/09
09/23/09
The longer I live the more I realize that people are just idiots. I think this has something to do with my theory that Darwin was wrong and the opposite is true.
09/23/09
I fear it may be accurate.
09/23/09
09/23/09
09/24/09
09/25/09
09/25/09
09/23/09
09/23/09
09/23/09
I'm at a loss for words to describe how this makes me feel...
09/23/09
No mention of the TVR that got toasted...
link to the list...[www.cars.gov]