Jalopnik 
Enter your username and password.
-
posts about #2012bmw1series more → 
2012 BMW 1-Series May Go Retro, Lose Some Weight
2011 BMW 1-Series Hatch Test Mule
Detroit, 2:17 AM
Tue Nov 24
23 posts in the last 24 hours
Tip your editors:
tips@jalopnik.com
Editor-in-Chief:
Ray Wert | Email | AIM
Road Test Editor:
Wes Siler | Email
Weekend Editor:
Murilee Martin | Email
Associate Editor - Houston:
Matt Hardigree
Associate Editor - Detroit:
Ben Wojdyla
Editor-at-Large:
Mike Spinelli
Contributors:
Mark Arnold
John Krewson | Email
Andy Didorosi
| posts about #2012bmw1series more → |
2012 BMW 1-Series May Go Retro, Lose Some Weight |
2011 BMW 1-Series Hatch Test Mule |
Original material is licensed under a Creative Commons License permitting non-commercial sharing with attribution.
03/17/09
03/17/09
...oh, yeah, fuck it then.
03/17/09
03/17/09
For the last 10 years, manufacturers have been showing us awesome, then running awesome through the focus groups until it comes out mangled crap. The only exceptions to this are put at rediculous price points where very few can afford them.
03/17/09
03/17/09
03/17/09
03/17/09
03/17/09
03/17/09
... wait for it...
Aztek!
YUK!
03/17/09
03/17/09
03/17/09
03/17/09
And taking retro cues doesn't mean remaking the old car. If that car was in showrooms I'd buy it yesterday.
Also, just because something was ruined by bean counters and non-designers on one car doesn't mean it'll fail on everything else.
I'd love to see the design you'd come up with, and no you can't just use the old car.
03/17/09
/ducks
I just know that many of the commenters around here love to pile the hate on anything he is/was associated with so to say that something is worse than Bangle is a great insult in the Jalopnoverse.
03/17/09
03/17/09
Are you trolling? By boxes on wheels you aren't referring to the E46, E39, E38, E36, E34, E30, E28, E24, E21, E12, E9, are you? Try and imagine yourself 50 years from now looking back at the BMW time line, how do you explain the era when Bangle took over?
BMW's teutonic design language was conservative, clean, coldly precise, etc. and that's why I loved them. I don't hate Bangle's designs, I actually like some of them, I just hate that he had to use BMW as the platform to launch them into the world. I liked BMW just the way it was, Mercedes would have been a much better fit for Bangle.
03/17/09
It isn't really a rallying thing, it's more like... Bangle styles vehicles controversially. A lot of people are vocal about hating them, but last I checked they're still selling BMWs all over the place, so.
03/17/09
"I liked BMW just the way it was, Mercedes would have been a much better fit for Bangle."
That's my main problem with Bangle. At that time, BMW couldn't afford to do risky designs. Mercedes could. But because of those designs they're where they are today.
03/18/09
Are you trolling? By boxes on wheels you aren't referring to the E46, E39, E38, E36, E34, E30, E28, E24, E21, E12, E9, are you? Try and imagine yourself 50 years from now looking back at the BMW time line, how do you explain the era when Bangle took over?
The E46, E38, E39 were styled after Bangle took over.
03/18/09
03/18/09
03/17/09
03/17/09
03/17/09
03/17/09
I actually like the looks of the 1-coupe, but the ones I do see (and there aren't many) are driven by bleach-blonde hoebags who could drive through a brick wall at any moment.
On top of that, again, it's way too close to the 3 in price and weight. A relatively economical yet fun to drive 1 would be perfect.
03/18/09
I like the hatch enough to have one. Couldn't rock the coupe.
What's bad looking about that?
03/18/09
03/17/09
It will never be the ripped-and-raw 2002. Those glorious days of elbows-out driving are gone.
03/17/09
03/17/09
03/17/09
03/17/09
03/17/09
The 1-Series, while full of awesome in turbocharged guise, missed the E30-ish point by being a piggy and too close to the 3.
03/17/09
I expect the second option.