We expect 4chan to be a good place to meet bronies and possible sexual deviants, but not a place to get reasonable car-buying recommendations. It turns out their advice is actually not terrible.
We did update the list but went sensible instead, filling in the Elantra over the Civic, because we don't recommend the 2012 Civic to anyone. Maybe the 2013 Civic will be better. Also, they don't build the Cobalt anymore.